Sorry to have kept you waiting for so long! I was out of the country and cut myself off from the outside world. Never fear though, I am back, and ready to continue chronicling my saga with our dining room table.
The last time I wrote, we had gotten to prepping the pipes for the base of our table. While Tyler and I were doing this, we were also in the process of selecting a stain for tabletop. If I haven't said it already, Tyler and I usually have very distinct taste. Tyler likes bright, bold colors, while I gravitate towards dark jewel-tones or neutrals. Tyler likes modern/abstract art, whereas I prefer more traditional landscapes. Needless to say, our decision to buy anything is a lengthy process.
In anticipation of this, we bought no less than SEVEN different stains with the hope of shortening the journey. Yes, seven. We started out with six, and added one more at the end. We figured the more we started out with, the more quickly we'd be able to figure out what we wanted. Here are the first six we bought:
(Minwax Classic Grey, Minwax Early American, Minwax Golden Oak, Minwax Picked Oak, RustOleum Sunbleached Wood, and Minwax Weathered Oak)
I immediately like Minwax Early American the best, but held my breath waiting to hear what Tyler thought. Miraculously, he liked it best too! I think the way the stain highlighted the knot in the wood sold him. Hooray!! Early American gave the wood a very rich look, and we thought it would contrast nicely with the dark pipes below. To be 100% sure about our decision, we further tested our selection by using a double coat of stain, AND by purchasing one more stain - Minwax Dark Walnut - just to make sure we didn't want to go any darker.
While I liked the dark stain, Tyler thought it was too dark, but we both liked the double coat of Early American (on the right), and finalized our decision!
P.S. If you're interested in using one of the stains we didn't use, please feel free to leave a comment asking for it!